The Wrong Scorecard: Why Results Aren't Enough to Measure Leadership The Bigger Scorecard

16.11.26 04:49 PM - By Nicole Ursch

Introduction 

The coffee shop was ordinary enough that I cannot remember what either of us ordered. What I remember is walking through the door convinced I was about to resign from a job I cared about because my family needed more than I could give while recovering from postpartum depression. 

At that point in my career, I knew how to work. Give me a responsibility, a deadline, or a problem, and I would take it seriously. I had built a great deal of my identity around being productive, dependable, and able to get things done. 

Results matter. Commitments matter. But when leadership becomes part of our responsibility, the question has to become larger than whether the work got done. We need to consider what our leadership is creating in the people and organizations around us while the work is getting done.

The Scorecard You Didn't Know You Had 

A good friend once told me that, when we first met, I introduced myself as Nicole "gets shit done" Ursch. I do not remember saying it, but I also do not doubt him for a second. Early in my career, I was a worker bee, and I took real satisfaction in being the person others could count on. 

There was nothing wrong with that. Organizations need people who meet deadlines, honor commitments, and do good work. The problem was not my desire to accomplish things; it was how closely I had connected productivity with personal value. 

Getting things done had become more than something I did well. It had become the scorecard I used to measure whether I mattered. Many of us carry some version of that hidden scorecard: projects completed, problems solved, hours worked, targets met, praise earned, or the number of things only we seem able to handle. 

That scorecard can serve us for a while. It teaches us to be reliable and helps us earn opportunities. But leadership changes the work. We are no longer only executing what already exists; increasingly, we are building work, shaping decisions, allocating attention, and influencing what other people are able to do. 

A quick win takes less than five minutes. Open a note on your phone and finish this sentence: "At the end of a good workday, I usually feel valuable when I have _____." Then look at your answer. If it contains only output, speed, control, or visible achievement, your scorecard may be too small.

The goal is not to abandon results or become less ambitious. It is to notice the measure we are using before it becomes the only measure we have. A leader can deliver an impressive amount of work and still leave too little behind in the people doing it.

When Winning Isn't Enough 

A leadership scorecard built only around outcomes can miss a consequential part of the story. A team can hit its targets, launch the program, earn recognition, meet the deadline, and keep moving forward while someone in the room is diminished along the way. 

I learned that in a room set up classroom-style, with tall unfinished ceilings and large windows behind the presentation area. Our organization had received a national Diversity and Inclusion award that morning. I was standing at the front of the room with a clicker in my hand, ready to present an employee-development program, when my leader stood and congratulated Betsy "and team." 

The award reflected years of work by many people. I did not believe the work belonged to me, and I wanted it to grow far beyond any one person. But I had helped start the initiative, carried it when there was no committee to share it, and worked with others to build participation across the organization.

In those few words, I felt my contribution disappear. Then I had to give my presentation. 

By conventional measures, it was a good day. The organization had received national recognition, the Senior Leadership Team meeting continued, and the employee-development program was ready to move forward. No financial statement, performance dashboard, or project plan would have indicated that anything had gone wrong. 

But something had happened. The visible results remained intact while the human experience of the day changed. 

That is why leaders need a second set of questions alongside the usual operational ones. Before moving on from a successful outcome, pause and ask: Who did the work? Whose contribution became visible? Who had access to the room, the conversation, or the credit? What did people likely carry away from the interaction? 

This is not an argument for distributing praise carelessly or pretending every contribution is identical. Clear credit is part of clear leadership. We can acknowledge the collective effort without erasing the people whose work, judgment, and persistence made the effort possible. 

When pressure is high, leaders often default to what is fastest: answer the question ourselves, give the presentation ourselves, accept the compliment ourselves, or keep the relationship close because we built it. Sometimes that is appropriate. It is still worth asking whether our own visibility has become the default rather than a deliberate choice.

Expanding the Scorecard 

The Bigger Scorecard begins with a simple distinction: results tell us what got accomplished. They do not tell us the whole story of what our leadership created while accomplishing it. 

My conversation with Craig in that coffee shop showed me a different kind of leadership. I had arrived prepared to resign. He listened, then said something I was not expecting: "Write your own job description." 

The arrangement we created allowed me to work two half-days each week, remain connected to client engagement, focus on my health, and be present for my family. The immediate outcome was a workable role. But the effect was larger than the role itself. 

With more distance from the day-to-day activity of the organization, I began noticing possibilities I had not seen before. I recognized the absence of women at the highest levels of leadership and eventually helped launch a mentoring program for high-potential women. Craig also had me take that idea to a senior woman for feedback and present it myself to Executive Leadership. 

He could have presented the program without me. The organization might still have received a program. But his choices gave me access, experience, relationships, and confidence that I did not have before. 

That is stewardship: the responsibility to care for something that is not ours to own. Leadership gives us authority and influence, but the people, opportunities, relationships, and potential within our care are not possessions. They are entrusted to us for a season. 

You do not need an executive title to practice this. Choose one person, one meeting, or one piece of work this week. Instead of asking only, "How do I get this done?" add three questions: "What might this person become capable of carrying?" "What access could I share?" and "What will remain after my involvement ends?" 

Those questions will not always produce an easy answer. They will, however, widen the lens. They move us from measuring only what we can point to and say, "I did that," toward measuring what became stronger because we were there.

Conclusion

A bigger scorecard does not ask us to choose between results and people. It asks us to hold both. We remain responsible for performance, commitments, and organizational health while paying attention to the confidence, access, clarity, capability, and dignity our leadership leaves behind. 

Start with the hidden scorecard you are carrying now. Write down the results you are expected to produce, then add one human measure you want to protect: whose contribution is visible, who is gaining capability, who has access to opportunity, or what people experience when they bring you difficult news. Chapter 1 of "The Bigger Scorecard" introduces this foundation, and the rest of the book develops the practices of stewardship, decision-making, culture, opportunity, and leadership residue that follow from it. 

What would change if you measured this season of leadership not only by what you accomplished, but also by what became stronger because it spent time in your care?

Nicole Ursch

Nicole Ursch